# Decision Matrix Phase 2 v0.1
Date: 2026-04-19Purpose: decision-making consolidation of theorems remaining in the `in_proof` block.
## Scope phase 2
- F03, F08, F10- D04- A02, A03
## Decision rule (consistent with phase 1)
- `validated`: only with full closure protocol criteria + robust audit.- `revise`: partial/positive evidence but not yet sufficient for `validated`.- `reject`: Robust forgery.
## Decision matrix (phase 2)
| Theorem | Current evidence status | Decision phase 2 | Reason || --- | --- | --- | --- |
| F03 | proof sketch present, formal closure not certified in theorem-level audit | `revise` | requires finalized proof and independent verification || F08 | proof sketch present, no dedicated external verification package | `revise` | requires complete formal closure || F10 | proof sketch present, conservative reduction not yet audited end-to-end | `revise` | requires full demonstration and cross-layer check || D04 | in_proof theorem without multi-context finalized benchmark | `revise` | conclusive experimental validation is missing || A02 | defined protocol, dedicated cycle not completed with final audit | `revise` | complete benchmark evidence missing || A03 | defined protocol, dedicated cycle not completed with final audit | `revise` | complete benchmark evidence missing |
## Note
No phase 2 theorem is `reject` at the current date; the classification is conservativeand oriented towards pre-publication robustness.