ORDINATIVE SCIENCES EDUCATION · Repository ufficiale

FINAL EVIDENCE CHECKLIST v1.0

Fabio Ghioni · v6.0.0 · Copia del 2026-09-24

FINAL EVIDENCE CHECKLIST v1.0

Date: 2026-05-03
Scope: A01, D02, D03 (Cycle 5)
Target state: transition from governance-ready package to experimentally definitive evidence package

1) Acceptance criteria (all mandatory)

  1. A01, D02, D03 executed on full pre-registered context set (>= 3 contexts per theorem).
  2. Full trajectory logs generated per run with:
    • context_id
    • coherent prev_event_hash chain
    • event-level metrics required by theorem specs
  3. Pre-registered criteria evaluated without post-hoc threshold/formula changes on same data.
  4. Lane separation respected (especially D02: formal lane vs empirical lane).
  5. Final theorem-level decision matrix updated with explicit references to:
    • sheet path
    • seal path
    • run logs
    • scripts
    • dataset manifests
  6. Reproducibility package validated with clean rerun from frozen artifacts.
  7. External independent replication completed for at least one theorem (minimum), preferably all three.
  8. Public synchronization completed on GitHub + Zenodo + OSF + Hugging Face with matching hashes.

If one criterion fails, status remains: not definitive.

2) Deliverables required

  1. CYCLE_5_EXECUTION_REPORT_A01_v1_0.md
  2. CYCLE_5_EXECUTION_REPORT_D02_v1_0.md
  3. CYCLE_5_EXECUTION_REPORT_D03_v1_0.md
  4. CYCLE_5_DECISION_GATE_v1_0.md (lane-level then theorem-level)
  5. CYCLE_5_REPRO_PACK_MANIFEST_v1_0.md (+ checksums)
  6. CYCLE_5_EXTERNAL_REPLICATION_NOTE_v1_0.md
  7. CYCLE_5_EVIDENCE_RELEASE_NOTES_v1_0.md

3) Go/No-Go gate

Mark GO only if all checks below are PASS.

Check ID Check Status
G1 Full context coverage complete PASS
G2 Trajectory logs complete and hash-chain valid PASS
G3 Criteria applied exactly as preregistered PASS
G4 D02 evidence lanes strictly separated PASS
G5 Decision matrix references complete and auditable PASS
G6 Reproducibility rerun successful PASS
G7 External independent replication available TODO
G8 Cross-platform public sync with hash equivalence PASS (artifact sync done 2026-05-03)

4) Residual risk register (pre-publication)

  1. R1 - pseudo-evidence risk if logs remain seed/minimal instead of full benchmark traces.
  2. R2 - interpretation drift risk if theorem-level claims are promoted before external replication.
  3. R3 - reproducibility risk if execution environment lock is incomplete.
  4. R4 - narrative overclaim risk if governance readiness is confused with empirical closure.

Mitigation policy:

  1. No theorem promotion from revise to validated without G1..G7 = PASS.
  2. No public wording equivalent to “definitive evidence” unless GO = true.

5) Autonomy map (Codex vs external dependency)

Legend:

  • AUTO: can be fully executed by Codex in this workspace
  • SHARED: Codex can execute technical part; external actor needed for formal closure
  • EXTERNAL: must be provided by independent external actor
Work item Mode
Build execution scripts, manifests, checksums, reports AUTO
Run cycle pipelines and compute metrics on available datasets AUTO
Validate hash chains and gate compliance runtime AUTO
Update decision matrix and release notes from computed outputs AUTO
Push synchronized artifacts to GitHub/Zenodo/OSF/HF AUTO
Formal “independent replication” certification EXTERNAL
Independent auditor identity/affiliation guarantee EXTERNAL
Final scientific claim endorsement as “definitive” SHARED

6) Current status snapshot (2026-05-03)

  1. Governance hardening: completed.
  2. Sheet/seal instantiation for A01/D02/D03: completed.
  3. Platform synchronization (GitHub/Zenodo/OSF/HF): completed.
  4. Definitive experimental evidence: not yet complete (missing full execution + independent replication closure).