CYCLE 5 EXTERNAL REPLICATION NOTE v1.0

Date: 2026-05-04 External reviewer target: Solomon

Request

Please independently reproduce A01, D02, D03 decisions using the provided cycle5 artifacts.

Minimum checks

1. Verify checksum integrity from CYCLE_5_REPRO_PACK_MANIFEST_v1_0.md.
2. Re-run runtime/check_gate_compliance.py and confirm substantive compliance.
3. Recompute theorem metrics from datasets/cycle3_inputs and compare with JSON results.
4. Confirm lane separation handling in D02.
5. Confirm locked formula and thresholds in D03.

Replication outcome section (to be filled by external reviewer)

• Reproduced: yes/no
• Divergence notes:
• Auditor identity:
• Date:
• Signature: