Decision Matrix Phase 1 v0.1

Date: 2026-04-19Purpose: first decisional consolidation post Cycle 3-4 (D02, A01, D03).

Decision rule adopted (phase 1)

• validated only with robust evidence + complete protocol criteria + final audit without critical issues.- revise if positive evidence but dependent on proxy/setup yet to be strengthened.- reject if criteria consistently falsified.

Decision matrix (phase 1)

| Theorem | Synthetic evidence | Decision phase 1 | Reason || --- | --- | --- | --- | | D02 | PASS benchmark #1 + PASS benchmark #2 + audit PASS | revise | metric Phi still proxy; serve run with final canonical operational metric || A01 | PASS benchmark #1 + PASS benchmark #2 + audit PASS | revise | P_ord/P_cls comparison based on proxy scoring, to be consolidated with final target pipeline || D03 | Cycle 3 revise_needed, Cycle 4 revision PASS + stress PASS + audit PASS | revise | positive but recent review; requires further stabilization before validated |

Notes

This phase does not yet close global decisions on all theorems of the in_proof block.A phase 2 is needed with final consolidation on D04/A03 and alignment with the founding text.