Decision Matrix Final Unified v0.1

Date: 2026-04-19
Editorial clarification update: 2026-05-01
Purpose: unified theorem decision (validated/revise/reject) for the in_proof block.

Unified scope

Theorems in scope:

• F03, F08, F10
• D02, D03, D04
• A01, A02, A03

Total: 9 theorems.

Unified decision (v0.1)

Decision distribution

• validated: 0
• revise: 9
• reject: 0

Brief motivation

1. Differential/application evidence is positive but still partially dependent on setup/proxy and needs final consolidation.
2. The in_proof foundation block still needs theorem-level closure plus independent formal verification before promotion to validated.
3. The revise classification is technically correct under Chapter 8 Definition 8.12 (anti-circularity operational rule): for A01/D03/D02, current operational proxies do not yet satisfy the full four-part requirement (semantic definition + observable mapping + replicable procedure + pre-registered thresholding logic).
4. For the remaining six theorems in scope, revise is a precautionary baseline pending audits at comparable depth.

Operational consequence

Step 3 (final theorem decision) is completed as unified baseline v0.1.
Next priority is formal freeze hardening with:

• theorem-level closure for F03/F08/F10
• non-proxy operational metric consolidation for D02/A01
• dedicated validation hardening for D04/A02/A03